Okinawa: The Black Sheep
So I just watched a Lonely Planet tour guide video on Japan, Tokyo to Taiwan and found it all to be rather depressing. The video, judging by the clothing, was shot in the late 80's to early 90's and horribly portrays Japan. I think it perhaps did a middling job with mainland but a down right piss poor job about Okinawa.
First and foremost, I understand Okinawa has 50,000 US military members on it, this is worth noting.It -has- changed the Okinawan people. They speak English, western foods can be found and the influenced for foreigners can be clearly seen. However there is no need to highlight stores that sell military only items.
No mention of the Okinawan sweet potato stores, Okinawan soba, Shisa etc. Just clear revulsion that stores would sell shell casings, flight suits and other military crap. One in four Okinawan's died in WWII and the Japanese obsession with American culture was barely mentioned. I think it is only logical that a few of these stores still exist. Military stores are not on every corner, they are barely worth noting as something I have seen and experienced after living here for 3 years. They are not worth mentioning at all in 15 spot on Okinawa.
So moving on past the military.
Oh wait no, he goes to the Japanese Naval Underground headquarters. Nothing special to say about it, but we had to mention that it's the location of one of the biggest mass suicides. I think the western world is obsessed with Japanese suicide, at least old fashioned suicide.
Then we are off to Peace Prayer Park (again with out mentioning it). No mention of the park itself, the beautiful monuments, the wall of names (similar to the Vietnam memorial) or anything. What do we talk about? Suicide cliffs and how many Okinawan civilians killed themselves there. Seriously westerners just don't get it.
Now we are done with the military... but onto animal cruelty.
Next up the guy clearly went to Okinawa world though he doesn't say so (I recognized the stage there). No mention of Goyokusendo cave, which is pretty cool to see, no mention of the local beer brewed there (which is darned good), no mention of habu sake, no mention of shisa, dances, Esia, crafts, bingata. No he skips straight to the habu versus mongoos show. I understand that back then, they still fought the Habu and Mongoos instead of what they have now (a race in the water) but that's not the only thing there!
They use this as a segway into Okinawan bull fighting.
I have seen a bullfight here on Okinawa and they are pretty cool to see. I was hesitant at first, I thought it was like Spanish style bull fights but its just bull versus bull. It is harmless, the bulls never really get hurt, they are just competing for a mate. They butt heads and push each other and then one tucks tail and runs. But he watches it for 5 minutes, a bull looses a horn (very rare) and he feels they are abused. They eat better than their owners.
Dog fighting, now that is bad. Cock fighting, also bad. I can go on. In those cases the animals fight to kill or hurt as much as possible. Okinawan bull fighting is like watching two animals fight for a mate, like elephants charging each other. Do you know that they get massages while they fight? Sure it's different, but I honestly don't see much wrong with it. Once the bull runs, the fight is over and they will do anything to protect the running bull (though generally they don't have to).
They close out the bit on Okinawa with a short skit on ancient Okinawan music sung in a modern way. That's it. Modern music. So Okinawa has military, military stores, animal cruelty and music. After watching this whole show I was left with little desire to see Japan and no desire to see Okinawa. It is as if they left out all the good stuff about the island.
I understand mainland Japan has always viewed Okinawa a rural and a bit old fashioned, nothing to interesting. But it has a lot to offer. They didn't even mention the -world renowned- diving. The miles of beaches, it is an island of beaches fit for a king. I understand Shuri castle might not have been restored back then but Okinawa has so much to offer.
That is the worst travel program I have ever seen. As some one who has lived here for 3 years, it's just insulting. I wish the outside world could see Okinawa the way that I do... okay not quite the burning inferno that I see it as but the rest of it.
First and foremost, I understand Okinawa has 50,000 US military members on it, this is worth noting.It -has- changed the Okinawan people. They speak English, western foods can be found and the influenced for foreigners can be clearly seen. However there is no need to highlight stores that sell military only items.
No mention of the Okinawan sweet potato stores, Okinawan soba, Shisa etc. Just clear revulsion that stores would sell shell casings, flight suits and other military crap. One in four Okinawan's died in WWII and the Japanese obsession with American culture was barely mentioned. I think it is only logical that a few of these stores still exist. Military stores are not on every corner, they are barely worth noting as something I have seen and experienced after living here for 3 years. They are not worth mentioning at all in 15 spot on Okinawa.
So moving on past the military.
Oh wait no, he goes to the Japanese Naval Underground headquarters. Nothing special to say about it, but we had to mention that it's the location of one of the biggest mass suicides. I think the western world is obsessed with Japanese suicide, at least old fashioned suicide.
Then we are off to Peace Prayer Park (again with out mentioning it). No mention of the park itself, the beautiful monuments, the wall of names (similar to the Vietnam memorial) or anything. What do we talk about? Suicide cliffs and how many Okinawan civilians killed themselves there. Seriously westerners just don't get it.
Now we are done with the military... but onto animal cruelty.
Next up the guy clearly went to Okinawa world though he doesn't say so (I recognized the stage there). No mention of Goyokusendo cave, which is pretty cool to see, no mention of the local beer brewed there (which is darned good), no mention of habu sake, no mention of shisa, dances, Esia, crafts, bingata. No he skips straight to the habu versus mongoos show. I understand that back then, they still fought the Habu and Mongoos instead of what they have now (a race in the water) but that's not the only thing there!
They use this as a segway into Okinawan bull fighting.
I have seen a bullfight here on Okinawa and they are pretty cool to see. I was hesitant at first, I thought it was like Spanish style bull fights but its just bull versus bull. It is harmless, the bulls never really get hurt, they are just competing for a mate. They butt heads and push each other and then one tucks tail and runs. But he watches it for 5 minutes, a bull looses a horn (very rare) and he feels they are abused. They eat better than their owners.
Dog fighting, now that is bad. Cock fighting, also bad. I can go on. In those cases the animals fight to kill or hurt as much as possible. Okinawan bull fighting is like watching two animals fight for a mate, like elephants charging each other. Do you know that they get massages while they fight? Sure it's different, but I honestly don't see much wrong with it. Once the bull runs, the fight is over and they will do anything to protect the running bull (though generally they don't have to).
They close out the bit on Okinawa with a short skit on ancient Okinawan music sung in a modern way. That's it. Modern music. So Okinawa has military, military stores, animal cruelty and music. After watching this whole show I was left with little desire to see Japan and no desire to see Okinawa. It is as if they left out all the good stuff about the island.
I understand mainland Japan has always viewed Okinawa a rural and a bit old fashioned, nothing to interesting. But it has a lot to offer. They didn't even mention the -world renowned- diving. The miles of beaches, it is an island of beaches fit for a king. I understand Shuri castle might not have been restored back then but Okinawa has so much to offer.
That is the worst travel program I have ever seen. As some one who has lived here for 3 years, it's just insulting. I wish the outside world could see Okinawa the way that I do... okay not quite the burning inferno that I see it as but the rest of it.
Labels: Okinawa
Loading...